 |
| Afghan refugee Samia from Baghlan city, with her infant son, speaks to Geo News in Islamabad. — Screengrab via Geo News |
Between Hope and Uncertainty: Afghan Families Stranded in Pakistan
In the heart of Islamabad, at Argentina Park, nearly 300 Afghan families—once schoolteachers, police officers, and civil servants—now live under plastic sheets, their future clouded by cracked promises. Most fled Afghanistan in August 2021, escaping the Taliban’s grip. Their hope? To find refuge—not in Pakistan, but through resettlement to third countries. Instead, shifting policies by the U.S. and Western nations have left them stranded, their dreams of relocation slipping away. Among them is 24-year-old Samia from Baghlan, cradling her infant son, Daniyal. “We fled because our lives were at risk… but here too, there is no place for us,” she says.
Samia is not alone. Pari Noori, a seasoned police officer, and Shehnaz Alizadeh, a civil servant for over a decade, recalled lives of security and growth that disintegrated almost overnight. Both carried hopes and fears into the park—hopes now besieged by border policies and dwindling asylum options.
These families once held Afghan Citizen Cards or Proof of Registration (PoR), symbols of legal stay. But in a policy reversal, Pakistan has rescinded hundreds of thousands of such permits and launched mass deportations that left families everywhere unsure: where can they go if they cannot remain, nor progress to a safer future?
The urgency of their plight is amplified by global policy shifts. Germany’s relocation program—once providing safe passage to vulnerable Afghans—has now halted due to political changes, leaving around 2,400 refugees frozen in limbo. This comes alongside the suspension of U.S. refugee admissions that stranded thousands of Afghan applicants already approved for relocation.
The Weight of Uncertainty on Families and Futures
These displaced families carry not just luggage, but trauma: loss of homeland, broken routines, interrupted schooling, uncertain residency. Children born in Pakistan raise their first memories under tents, not classrooms, their education cut short.
The psychological burden is heavy—some have even died from despair. P1 and P2 case holders for U.S. relocation have reported suicides and heart attacks among those stuck in waiting. They are institutionalized traumas born not of conflict, but of abandonment.
Weak infrastructure and cranked resources compound the suffering. With deportation timelines compressed, families have no time to plan dignified exits. UNHCR and IOM implored Pakistani authorities for humane processes, fair timelines, and respect for documentation holders’ rights. But the crisis continues.
In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, a regional official insisted that deportations would be voluntary. At holding centers like Landi Kotal, refugees were surveyed, but not forced out—offering fleeting hope. Still, for those splitting weeks between tents and trucks, the promise of choice rings hollow.
Beyond Borders: Global Voices and Outcry
International agencies and host communities are sounding alarms. Just beyond Pakistan’s borders, families like the Hazara Christian couple in Texas were preparing for resettlement until suspensions halted their flights. Children once promised safety now sit in uncertain limbo, their future stuck in paperwork.
Meanwhile, the UK quietly evacuated at least one Afghan family after legal battles over a data breach exposed their identities. Other refugees, particularly those who worked with British forces, remain in hiding—redeemed by law but not by action.
Every policy change—stepped-up detentions, revoked asylum, shrinking relocation quotas—echoes painfully through the corridors of these makeshift camps. Among the stranded, some still cling to faith in relocated assurances; yet each delay deepens distrust and danger.
Repatriation’s Toll and Afghanistan’s Fragile Welcome
Returning doesn’t rest comfort. Many repatriated refugees report severe hardship: homes destroyed, livestock vanished, children left hungry, with no shelter in sight. Afghanistan’s Ministry of Urban Development is scrambling to build colonies for returnees, but the path ahead remains fogged by bitter uncertainty.
These aren’t statistics—they are displaced souls on a dehumanizing journey. Families uprooted. Parents agonizing over their children’s education. Communities shivering against tents and birthing minister announcements of relocation policies lacking heart.
From Despair to Humanity: A Call for Global Compassion
At the narrative’s center are thousands of nameless faces—women like Samia, children like Daniyal, professionals like Noori and Alizadeh—learning, day by fragile day, that their futures are not promised. Yet, some seeds of hope persist, as civil society, international bodies, and resettlement promises gather into a faint but resolute light.
What they need now is more than shelter. They need just processes, reinstated asylum programs, and global commitment to humanity. Every overdue relocation flight, every resumed U.S. or German resettlement policy, every diplomatic plea that echoes in corridors—they all inch toward restoring hope. Without them, these families’ dreams remain stranded in a park, where grass grows thinner than their options.
Samia is not alone. Pari Noori, a seasoned police officer, and Shehnaz Alizadeh, a civil servant for over a decade, recalled lives of security and growth that disintegrated almost overnight. Both carried hopes and fears into the park—hopes now besieged by border policies and dwindling asylum options.
These families once held Afghan Citizen Cards or Proof of Registration (PoR), symbols of legal stay. But in a policy reversal, Pakistan has rescinded hundreds of thousands of such permits and launched mass deportations that left families everywhere unsure: where can they go if they cannot remain, nor progress to a safer future?
The urgency of their plight is amplified by global policy shifts. Germany’s relocation program—once providing safe passage to vulnerable Afghans—has now halted due to political changes, leaving around 2,400 refugees frozen in limbo. This comes alongside the suspension of U.S. refugee admissions that stranded thousands of Afghan applicants already approved for relocation.
The Weight of Uncertainty on Families and Futures
These displaced families carry not just luggage, but trauma: loss of homeland, broken routines, interrupted schooling, uncertain residency. Children born in Pakistan raise their first memories under tents, not classrooms, their education cut short.
The psychological burden is heavy—some have even died from despair. P1 and P2 case holders for U.S. relocation have reported suicides and heart attacks among those stuck in waiting. They are institutionalized traumas born not of conflict, but of abandonment.
Weak infrastructure and cranked resources compound the suffering. With deportation timelines compressed, families have no time to plan dignified exits. UNHCR and IOM implored Pakistani authorities for humane processes, fair timelines, and respect for documentation holders’ rights. But the crisis continues.
In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, a regional official insisted that deportations would be voluntary. At holding centers like Landi Kotal, refugees were surveyed, but not forced out—offering fleeting hope. Still, for those splitting weeks between tents and trucks, the promise of choice rings hollow.
Beyond Borders: Global Voices and Outcry
International agencies and host communities are sounding alarms. Just beyond Pakistan’s borders, families like the Hazara Christian couple in Texas were preparing for resettlement until suspensions halted their flights. Children once promised safety now sit in uncertain limbo, their future stuck in paperwork.
Meanwhile, the UK quietly evacuated at least one Afghan family after legal battles over a data breach exposed their identities. Other refugees, particularly those who worked with British forces, remain in hiding—redeemed by law but not by action.
Every policy change—stepped-up detentions, revoked asylum, shrinking relocation quotas—echoes painfully through the corridors of these makeshift camps. Among the stranded, some still cling to faith in relocated assurances; yet each delay deepens distrust and danger.
Repatriation’s Toll and Afghanistan’s Fragile Welcome
Returning doesn’t rest comfort. Many repatriated refugees report severe hardship: homes destroyed, livestock vanished, children left hungry, with no shelter in sight. Afghanistan’s Ministry of Urban Development is scrambling to build colonies for returnees, but the path ahead remains fogged by bitter uncertainty.
These aren’t statistics—they are displaced souls on a dehumanizing journey. Families uprooted. Parents agonizing over their children’s education. Communities shivering against tents and birthing minister announcements of relocation policies lacking heart.
From Despair to Humanity: A Call for Global Compassion
At the narrative’s center are thousands of nameless faces—women like Samia, children like Daniyal, professionals like Noori and Alizadeh—learning, day by fragile day, that their futures are not promised. Yet, some seeds of hope persist, as civil society, international bodies, and resettlement promises gather into a faint but resolute light.
What they need now is more than shelter. They need just processes, reinstated asylum programs, and global commitment to humanity. Every overdue relocation flight, every resumed U.S. or German resettlement policy, every diplomatic plea that echoes in corridors—they all inch toward restoring hope. Without them, these families’ dreams remain stranded in a park, where grass grows thinner than their options.
Tags
National